Brooklyn Bedding8.4
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid
One of the few genuinely medium mattresses in a category where almost everything measures 6 or higher. Factory-direct pricing, three real firmness options.
Foam hybrid$1,165 Queen30 nights tested
Brand guide · Founded 1995 · Phoenix, Arizona
Brooklyn Bedding mattresses, reviewed
A factory-direct manufacturer that has been building mattresses since 1995. Three firmness choices on the flagship and the best price-per-quality ratio we track.
- Models reviewed
- 1
- Best score
- 8.4
- Trial
- 120 nights
- Warranty
- 10 years, limited
We buy or independently request every mattress we test. If you buy through a link here we may earn a commission, which never affects our ranking. How this works.
What Brooklyn Bedding is good at
Brooklyn Bedding owns its Phoenix factory and has been making mattresses since 1995, which is roughly two decades longer than most of the brands it now competes with online. Cutting out the middle layer is the whole pitch, and the pricing reflects it.
The Signature Hybrid comes in Soft, Medium and Firm, ordered at checkout, and the Medium is one of the few genuinely medium mattresses in a category where almost everything measures 6 or higher on our gauge.
Where it gives ground to the $1,800 hybrids is finish and long-term data. The cover and quilting are plainer, and we have three years of sag measurements rather than five.
Strengths
- Factory-direct pricing — a Queen Signature is under $1,200
- Three real firmness options, not marketing labels
- Made in the United States in the company’s own plant
- Responsive hybrid feel that suits combination sleepers
Watch out for
- 120-night trial with a $99 return fee
- Cover and quilting are plainer than the premium hybrids
- 10-year warranty rather than lifetime
- Shipping
- Free compressed shipping in the contiguous US.
- Returns
- 120-night trial with a $99 return fee.
Every Brooklyn Bedding mattress we have tested
Where these mattresses rank
Read how we test to see exactly what each score means.